We let the rookie pick again, and this time it was even better than the last.
His selection was @pizzeriamagpie, and we had a great time with great drinks and even better pizza.
Our selections were on both extremes. A simple but delicious Margherita pizza featuring a fat burrata in the center and the more elaborate pizza of the day: a fantastic, cheesy, ranch buffalo chicken pie.
The superior quality of both these pizzas made us wish we had more, and we can’t wait to go back to try the rest of the menu.
For dessert, we had an incredible citrus ricotta cheesecake that we’re still dreaming of. It was even better than it looked.
We were given a lollipop with our bill, and as someone who’s gotten too old to receive one from the doctor when they get a vaccination, I really appreciated that. (It was lime, too! My favourite. 😊)

May 23rd, 2024 – Pizza Quest stop 16 – Pizzeria Magpie
Overall Score: 9.4/10
Ordered: Magpie Margherita, Buffalo Chicken (pizza of the day), Bourbon Lemonade, Gâteau au Fromage